Thursday, November 19, 2026

THE DONOHUE DOCTRINE

In Watertown, over the past few years, there has been a war of words. If you read this blog, if you regularly check out the comments section of Watertown News, if you are a regular visitor to the social media sites where residents, old and new, weigh-in, you have heard the very heated argument about housing.

One side of that argument goes like this:

We are in the midst of a national housing emergency. Watertown is morally obligated to create as many housing units as we possibly can. And we need to do it now!

And the other side goes like this:

Watertown has done its part. Unlike many other communities, we have steadily been adding new housing. Aggressively cramming housing units into our four square mile footprint will adversely affect the quality of life for those who currently live here.

The argument is highly emotional and will likely continue well into the future. The question is: How will our elected representatives – the nine individuals charged with making practical decisions – act in the best interests of the still somewhat townish city of Watertown?

In his November 10 letter to the editor, titled: Protecting Watertown’s Future Through Responsible Development, former Town Councilor J.D. Donohue offers something more substantial than another opinion about housing development in Watertown. His letter lays out a set of principles for evaluating the consequences of future growth.

It’s an important call to action that I think it deserves a name that fits the message: The Donohue Doctrine.

Some readers might consider this to be a case of a former town councilor firing a shot across the bow of the current council.

 They might be right.

 But I see the Donohue Doctrine as a helpful commonsense guide for the councilors who sometimes get caught up in feel-good issues that have nothing to do with being a city councilor. (Don’t worry about me not calling them out. They know who they are), and also for those councilors conspicuous for not doing their homework (They also know who they are).

The Donohue Doctrine, at its heart, is a straightforward proposition: Watertown should not make decisions about future growth without first understanding their cumulative consequences.

How much additional housing can our schools accommodate? What will be the long-term impact on municipal services and infrastructure? How will the changing balance between commercial and residential property affect the tax burden on existing homeowners? And how do individual development proposals fit into a comprehensive vision for the city's future?

These are not questions that should be answered after major commitments have already been made. They should be asked and answered before those commitments are made.

The  Donohue Doctrine does not call for an end to housing development. It calls for development decisions to be subjected to a broader test of their cumulative consequences – being proactive, not reactive − a position that every single councilor should get behind, even the ones who have to drag themselves kicking and screaming to that commonsense position.

I, for one, will be making pocket-size editions of the Donohue Doctrine to carry around with me. The next time I get into a local politics discussion at the Stop & Shop (usually in the produce section or the parking lot) I will hand it over as a parting gift.

Protecting Watertown’s Future Through Responsible Development, soon to be known as: The Donohue Doctrine.

 

Bruce Coltin, The Battle For Watertown

 

  

No comments:

Post a Comment

THE DONOHUE DOCTRINE

In Watertown, over the past few years, there has been a war of words. If you read this blog, if you regularly check out the comments secti...